Jeremy Warsh has been in off-mode ever since his grandpa's death a couple years ago. He set aside their shared passion, comic art, and hasn't looked back. As an introvert from the other side of town, he fully expects to spend his boring life bagging groceries until, maybe one day, he's promoted to store manager.

Yet, his two best friends, Kasey and Stuart, are different. They're not afraid to demand more out of everyone. When Kasey comes out, Jeremy's inspired. He picks up his colored pencils and starts drawing comics again, creating a no-nonsense, truth-talking character named Penny Kind. Who speaks to him. Literally.

The friend-group sets in motion Stuart's plans for a huge Homecoming prank, and if they can get Penny's comic trending, they might be able to pull it off. Could this be a stepping-stone to a future Jeremy's only dreamed of? And after he kisses a boy at a college party, will Jeremy finally face what he's been hiding from?