Amish girl Lucy Fuller is concerned about many things; particularly the diminishing Amish farmland in Lancaster County.

When the handsome Joshua Hershberger returns from his long rumspringa, she does her best to resist her attraction to him. Only because he was once betrothed to her older sister.

Lucy assumes he has returned to take control of his parents' farm. What will she do when she finds he has not come back to re-join the Amish community? And worse, he is hiding more than one secret?