Identical twin sisters Justice and Liberty Pope have their looks and a Christmas birthday in common, but very little else. Justice is a busy California divorce attorney who spends her days surrounded by hostile clients wanting out of their miserable relationships. Justice no longer believes in happy endings, understandably, but her boyfriend is pushing for a long-term commitment. 
Liberty is an up-and-coming singer with dangerous curves and killer vocals who is sick of the fast life. The music industry is crammed with superficial personalities, including her player boyfriend, and she secretly longs for the kind of love her parents have; something true that lasts a lifetime.
A heated conversation sparks a little sisterly feud while the family is gathered for Thanksgiving dinner. Both women are convinced the other has the perfect life so they decide to play a harmless game of switching identities. No big deal. They did it often as teenagers. 
Things go exactly as planned until Liberty begins to fall hard for Justice's attentive, sexy boyfriend. Meanwhile, Justice is really starting to appreciate the no-strings-attached relationship Liberty's passionate lover is offering. The men notice the sudden transformation in their behavior, but chalk it up to a simple change of heart—completely unaware the sisters are twins. When the women take their new partners home for Christmas dinner, will they be able to continue the hoax and fool the family too? Or will they be forced to return the best gifts they've ever received?