Now Rose has married, Nancy Yoder turns her attention to Tulip. Will Nancy need to be so forceful with finding Tulip a husband? After all, Tulip is her smart daughter.
While Nancy is occupied organizing community events, Tulip agrees to go on a buggy ride with someone her mother would not approve of, and then meets another man, Wilhem, who is exactly the person she imagined herself with.
How will she cancel the first man without hurting his feelings? What if Wilhem finds out that he was not her first choice?
Throughout Tulip's dilemmas, her younger twin sisters make things more difficult.