Lauren Daly is fed up with her dead-end job, frustrating roommates, and unhealthy love life. She escapes to The Dollhouse, New Jersey's hottest lesbian bar, where disappearing in a crowd of gorgeous women is exactly what she needs at the end of the day. But when the owner, Berit Matthews, approaches her for a casual hookup, Lauren pushes her away, knowing better than to put her heart on the line for a playgirl.

Berit loves her bar, her life, and the casual connections she has with the women around her. She can't help her simmering attraction for Lauren, though, and Lauren's rejection challenges her to prove she's capable of friendship, kindness, and even matchmaking. Berit's efforts draw them closer than either expected, but when The Dollhouse is threatened, they're forced to fight for their sanctuary and their newfound love.