On one of the worst days of Autumn Whittaker's life, she meets Deputy Dean Thompson when he pulls her over—twice—for traffic violations. Though he smells heavenly and has a killer smile, she'd be more than happy to never see him again. She soon discovers that won't be possible: he's her Friday night blind date.
As much as she wants to keep her distance, Autumn feels her resolve crumbling when she repeatedly bumps into Dean, discovering there's more to him than just the upstanding law officer that she first met. He's everything that Autumn's controlling, manipulative former fiancé, Jason, was not, and soon, she realizes that Dean might be the key to getting over her ex and finding true love.
With everything going so perfectly, Autumn's heart is shattered when Dean and Autumn run into Jason, and he reminds her that she's average, ordinary, and boring. Can Dean show her that she has what it takes to make her own happily ever after?