Dorothy's life is too complicated for things like commitment and long term relationships. But if she were to hook up with someone, it would be Matthew Bradley… The gorgeous guy from Sales with the heart-melting smile, and smooth-as-chocolate voice. The problem is, he's too busy noticing every other woman in the office to give Dorothy the time of day.

Enter Ben. He's friendly, as a fellow programmer he gets her, and Dorothy has to admit he looks pretty sexy in a tux. He offers his services as her fake boyfriend for the company Christmas party, strictly to make Matthew jealous of course, and Dorothy jumps at the chance.

When it turns out Ben wants more than a pretend girlfriend, Dorothy has to decide if she's holding out for the implausible when someone impossibly wonderful is already by her side.