When they both make the same wish on the same star at the same moment, Luke and Ashleigh learn that there's more to love than making wishes.

Ashleigh Cartwright fell in love with Luke the first time she met him on a blind date The second time she fell in love with him, she accidentally won the bid for a date with their cooking teacher. She meant to bid 25 hours of community service and accidentally bid 250.

In the midst of the chaos, Ashleigh decides she won't let Luke's piercing green eyes, or the chef's charming accent, trick her into falling for men that are definitely out of her league.

Luke Godel moved to Ashbrook, Montana because his childhood friend Peter Pederson told him it was a place where people liked to settle down. In the first year he's lived there, Luke helped two of his love interest get married to other men. Thinking he's always going to be a groomsman and never the groom, Luke almost misses his chance for love.

Forgetting that life has a way of making wishes come true—especially when they are made on stars, Ashleigh and Luke get in the way of their own good intentions. Will their pride keep them from seeing the answer to their wish? Or, can they learn from the Ashbrook community that love always has a way of making dreams come true?