Tyler Cooper can't love. It's not that he doesn't want to, but he can't. After all, cupids are great at love, just not their own. His job is to help others find their happy ever afters and keep the magical town safe from outsiders as the town sheriff. Only he never expected her.

Abigail Clark needs to move on. She's been in love with Tyler since they were kids and he's never truly seen her. She knows she's not for him and now needs a new chance outside of Holiday.

Yet when cupid's arrow hits true, the two find that leaving town might be out of the question. And when someone from Tyler's past threatens everything they're trying to build, it will take the town of Holiday—quirks and all—to save them both.