Garrett, a retired Army scout, returns home to the Oldest City in the United States, to open his own roastery, one of his lifelong dreams. But more than his love for coffee, Garrett has always wanted to be a dad. After many failed relationships, and what seems like a permanently broken heart, he decides to make fatherhood a reality on his own terms, and forge his way through the adoption process.

Debbie is a youth advocate with a local adoption organization, who loves her job and the children they represent. St. Augustine is a new city for her, but she quickly falls in love with the small shops and businesses that line the downtown area. While she's content in her professional life, she still feels something is missing. Even being in the most romantic city in the country can't make up for her terrible dating experiences, and she swears off men, convinced it just isn't in the cards for her.

When Debbie walks into Garrett’s shop, looking for sponsors for her fundraiser, it appears fate is on his side, and he’ll finally become the parent he’d always wanted to be. But when disaster threatens to strike, Garrett may get more than he bargained for.

Will a good cup of coffee be all it takes for love to find its way through this romantic Old City?