Mandy Hostetler is a young Amish woman that is a bit unconventional, she is the best in her town at both best at both baseball and baking pies...as well as being a sought for beauty. But Mandy has a broken past and has vowed to remain single. This draws the shame and ire of her family and friends alike. A young English doctor comes to town, however, and pays a few house visits in the community. He is educated in the ways of the Amish and has sought this line of work because he, too, has spurned the idea of a marital relationship. A freak accident to Mandy's grandmother places the two of them together and over time, the spark of attraction grows... But will their stubborn determination to remain single cost them both the chance to know true love?