Ben Castillo was every woman's fantasy. More precisely, Faith O'Leary's fantasy. Tall, broad, and oh-so handsome, he had a deep voice, big hands, and the best part of all- he was just as kinky as the rumors suggested. Even kinkier. When he agreed to help her explore her submissive nature, she mistakenly thought her biggest obstacle would be in getting Ben to believe her when she said she wasn't going to walk away after his tutelage was over. Instead she finds herself facing the scorn of their conservative community when it's discovered that their relationship also included time spent with his cute roommate Colby.

Ben was convinced his time with Faith was limited and she'd move on to someone closer to her own age and settle down once she had her fun. The vicious gossip going around town is a sign for him to walk away from the woman he's come to love, but Colby thinks Ben's a fool, and will do whatever he can to ensure a happy ending. For all of them.