Cindy Morrow is busy trying to keep a promise to her mother who died in an automobile accident, and she’s determined to make her cookie store a success. Widower, Jonathan Griffin, is busy raising his five-year-old twins after his wife died in the same accident over a year ago. Neither of them have the time or inclination to even think of how much they long for someone to share their lives with. 
But Jonathan’s twins want a mommy for Christmas and they’ve bonded with Cindy. If Santa can’t bring them a new mommy, they’ll pray for one. Their daddy says God answers prayers and they are sure He’s going to answer this one. And if He needs any help, they are more than willing to do all they can to get the two together. With God on their side, how can their daddy and Miss Cindy resist each other?