Twenty-three year old Sebastian Rook, a rookie physical therapist, finds himself lusting after two men — his sexy roommate, Ben Hull, who is a model for local advertisers; and the Vanmer Vipers' all-star quarterback, Jory Sole, who also happens to be one of Sebastian's patients. As Sebastian attempts to bed the football player, his sexual interest in his roommate heightens. But Jory is very hard to land, let alone date, and Ben happens to be straight, even though he's interested in Sebastian.
Confused, Sebastian decides to set his sights on not one but both men. Unfortunately, when Ben learns of Sebastian's sexual escapade with Jory, he turns sour. What transpires among the three men is sexually complex.
Ben's girlfriend Zoe learns about the threesome and, outraged, destroys Sebastian's relationships with both men, leaving him heartbroken. As the holidays approach, Sebastian feels lost. A decision has to be made. Who does he love more, Ben or Jory?