P.J. Benson knows Sheriff's Detective Wade Kingsley wouldn't blow up his own boat to kill his ex-wife and her new husband, Michael Brewster. Sure, Wade wasn't happy that his ex was taking their six-year-old son, Jason, to live in California, but Wade and Jason were also onboard the boat when it blew up. Wade would never have endangered his son that way. Nevertheless, the investigating detectives consider Wade their prime suspect, and Wade's ex in-laws loudly accuse him and threaten to file for custody of Jason. Under the circumstances, P.J. is certain this isn't the right time to tell Wade she's pregnant, but bouts of morning sickness give her away. Wade is upset by the news. P.J. wonders if it's because he's afraid he'll be put in prison for a double homicide he didn't commit, or if he's afraid the new baby will cause P.J. to become schizophrenic, as was the case with her mother. Even P.J. is worried about that. Although Wade doesn't want her playing detective, P.J. soon discovers that Michael Brewster wasn't as great a guy as everyone thought. But did anyone hate the man enough to kill him?