Sara Goode is leading an exciting life in New York until her radio talk show is cancelled. She heeds the advice of a homeless woman—who insists she speaks with angels—and returns to Bland, Virginia for Thanksgiving. But not everyone in the small town is happy to see her. Sara learns there is more to forgiveness than just receiving, but granting it as well. It doesn't hurt that she's falling for the town's most eligible bachelor, Luke Sterling, the handsome minister of her family's church. Luke has his own connection to NYC. He also has rejection angst since going from "college football field hero" to "has been" overnight. Can they face their fears and embrace love? Manhattan's bright lights still call to Sara, and Luke's fears of being rebuffed may just be too deep to overcome.