At her boss's invitation, Jayne Milestone attends an exclusive masquerade ball held at one of New York's most luxurious hotels. That night, dressed as Cleopatra, Jayne has her heart and body stolen by an irresistible man disguised as Zorro. Could the mystery man be her coworker Jonathan, who she's pined after for so long? The following day at the office, Jayne kisses Jonathan as a thank-you for the wonderful evening, only to realize the next moment that his lips aren't Zorro's! Pale as a ghost, Jayne desperately tries to recount that magical night. Just who on earth did she sleep with?