Former librarian Jessica Martin is about a dozen cats away from embracing her inner spinster. At twenty-six, she's not only still a virgin, she hasn't even been kissed since high school. Her vivacious twin sister, Jamie, keeps trying to set her up with completely unsuitable guys. Prince Charming seems more like a cruel joke than ever until Detective Duncan Reinhold walks into Jessie's vintage bookstore looking for a missing girl. He's everything she's ever dreamed of, but hopelessly out of her league. Can she overcome a lifetime of insecurity and believe he's fallen for her?

Duncan Reinhold isn't looking for love. In fact, it's the very last thing on his mind when he meets Jessie. He's looking for a missing girl, and he needs to remain focused on the search. But his attraction to Jessie can't be denied and he finds himself in a completely inappropriate clinch with the beautiful bookstore owner within minutes of their first meeting. He knows instantly that she is the one. Can he overcome the complications between them and his own loveless past to convince her that he's interested in being not just her first lover, but also her one and only true love?