Everyone expects Rebecca Winston to marry her high school/college sweetheart, Garrett Langley. The problem is, the flame's gone out on their romance. They're still best of friends, but only friends. When Garrett's father has a heart attack, his older brother Wyatt (an L.A. attorney) returns home for the first time in years. The attraction between Rebecca and Wyatt is immediate. Can Rebecca expect her family and, especially, Garrett to understand that her desires have changed and turned toward Wyatt? Can Wyatt get past the feeling that he's poaching his younger brother's girl?