Forty-year-old Alex Spencer has given up on love. Having escaped five years earlier from the verbally abusive and two decades older, Trent Peterson, her life revolves around her daughter, sixteen-year-old Josie, even if Josie wants nothing to do with her. But with Valentine's Day looming, Alex's high school sweetheart, Billy Leibowitz, whom she kicked out of her life twenty years earlier thanks to Trent's demands, has been invading her thoughts. Alex searches for Billy in vain—it seems as if he's simply disappeared. Suddenly, Candy Hearts, which Billy sent to Alex every Valentine's Day, start arriving in the mail. Is Billy sending the Candy Hearts? Will this finally be her chance at happily ever after?