The Magic Jukebox sits in the Faulk Street Tavern in the quiet seaside town of Brogan's Point, Massachusetts. No one knows what classic rock songs will come out of the jukebox when a coin is inserted, but every now and then, the jukebox will play a song that casts a spell on two bar patrons—a song that will change their lives and open their hearts to love.

Monica Reinhart is a good girl. A hometown girl. After college, she returned to Brogan's Point to help run the family business, an oceanfront inn. She's never done a wild thing in her life. When Ty Cronin sails into town, his wildness intrigues her. When the jukebox plays "Wild Thing," that wildness infects her, and soon she finds herself doing things she never would have imagined. But Ty could be big trouble. She hardly knows him. She mustn't trust him. Yet once she's taken a walk on the wild side with him, how can she go back to being a good hometown girl?