Wiley is a wacky witch whose spells tend to fail. She refuses to date handsome rich men because of her ex-husband, and wants only a kind and caring man in her life.

When Ryder, a competent wizard, finds her in a restaurant in the town of Salem, he's wary because he's been bitten by the divorce bug. He wants to find a woman who could love him for himself.

Disguised as a balding, poor man, he finds Wiley fascinating. When she falls for him, she opens her heart. The only problem is that she hates liars. How can he convince her that he's the right man for her? It's a game of hearts in this sweet tale of love.