In the small town of Stubborn, West Virginia, 1880, happily single Cassandra Holloway has decided to come out to her father, Walter, on the eve of Valentine's Day. Before she can reveal being a woman of "two-spirits" her well-intentioned, but offspring obsessed father has set her up on another blind date with someone named Morgan. When Cassandra attempts to cancel the date she is faced with a first. She must choose between a beautiful, deaf Astronomy Professor at the local University or the Professors' handsome sign-language interpreter— both named Morgan.With a comedy filled evening that Cassandra's cupid playing father could not have planned, she must make a choice as the sun rises on Valentine's Day.Which Morgan will be her Valentine?