Laura Henderson is tired of being alone. She and her two best friends make a pact - every major holiday for one year they'll go out specifically to meet a guy, in hopes that they'll each find their one true love. It's not cheating if the guy she invites to meet her on their first holiday out is a man she's been chatting with online for months, right? Especially considering she doesn't even know his name.

But Mr. Mysterious is hiding more than just his identity and soon Laura is faced with a decision that will change her relationship with her friends - and the course of her life.