Amish woman, Rachael Zook, loved Elijah Yoder, but he made a mistake and got shunned. He left the Amish to join a biker's club, leaving her heart-broken.

However, handsome Amish man, Jeremiah Troyer, fills in the gap that Elijah had left; however, there is a major problem: Rachael's grandfather, Ben, keeps comparing him to Elijah.

Setting out to prove himself fit for taking Rachael's hand in marriage, Jeremiah moves to Shipshewana to work on her brother's dairy farm. However, there are secrets that Jeremiah is keeping from Rachael.

One winter morning, Rachael comes head-first with Jeremiah's secrets and is faced to deal with her own transgressions. Can God help her heal? Will he forgive her for her sins? Will she forgive herself and find true love?