Alyssa and Nolan are about to be married when Nolan's best friend, Zeke, arrives. He's an enigmatic figure, rumored to be excommunicated and to have failed to complete his mission for the Church. Alyssa sensibly marries Nolan, who is good-looking, devout, sensitive, and loving, but conventional. Unfortunately, being married in the temple doesn't help Alyssa put aside her attraction to Zeke.