Evelyn works at the Goodwill, but her love and compassion for people and her propensity for solving mysteries has made her well known among the homeless community. When she is introduced to John Doe, who is suffering from amnesia after a bicycle accident, she jumps at the chance to help him solve the mystery of his identity.

No one has reported John as missing and his fingerprints aren't in any databases. But as Evelyn and her friend, Grandpa Joe, help guide John through his walk as a new Christian, John begins to trust that in God's eyes, the man he was no longer exists. Can he learn the truth about his past? And if he does, will his newfound faith survive?