Readers, can you believe it? Sutter Traub is back in town! It's been five years since that handsome wrangler took off for Seattle, but no one 'round here has forgotten. Especially not Paige Dalton, the devoted schoolteacher everyone thought he was going to marry...

The rumor mill abounds. No one is quite sure what has brought Sutter home after all this time – or whether he is deserving of a second chance. But we are betting there's a certain brown–eyed beauty with a special request on her Christmas list. Maybe the power of forgiveness will bring the mighty maverick home for the holidays – for good!