Chase has obsessed over his coworker Dylan to the point of nicknaming him Mr. Perfect. His social anxiety prevents him from actually approaching his crush, until a chance encounter forces an interaction. When Dylan discovers the nickname, his promiscuous ways won't let this opportunity pass him by. Pursuing Chase is more challenging than he expected, since even a conversation with Chase is a struggle. To help win him over, Dylan adopts a mangy stray dog that's been hiding under his porch. The dog turns out to be even more emotionally broken than Chase is. Despite his own flaws and concern that he won't live up to Chase's expectations, Dylan might just be the man both of them need to help them heal their past wounds.