With the Henrys still reeling from the surprise return of Holly's father and Harriet hired as chief of police on Whitewitch Island, Georgia has more than enough to juggle without a murder complicating matters. But when a suspicious stranger asking about Olive's long-lost husband turns up dead, Harriet is on the hook and under the microscope, which means she's asking Georgia for help. Can they solve the mystery, protect Olive and Holly and keep Harriet's job intact before the new mayor and council rethink their choice? All while Elias Barrow finally decides it's time to tell Georgia everything...