A veteran with scars, a single dad with doubts, and a Christmas neither will forget.

Veteran Maggie Majors is in Pine Hill, Kentucky on a mission, not to get involved in the town's over-the-top Christmas festivities. None-the-less, she's judging their "Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer" contest. Twinkling lights, silver tinsel, and a borrowed princess costume aren't going to fix the holes in her tortured-by-the-past heart, but Maggie will do anything to make the most of the second chance she's been gifted. Even co-judge the games with a man who makes her insides jittery.

Firefighter Walker Bailey isn't looking for romance, much less a fairytale happy-ever-after. He'd loved, lost, and been left a single dad. But spending time with Maggie has him adding her to the top of his Christmas wish list. If only he believed Santa could deliver the gift of love...

Can the spirit of Christmas bind their hearts, giving them a faith in love that can conquer their pasts?