It's Evil... Oh, So Evil... Matt Robbins and his twin sister Erica are new to the city of Westwood. While both teens are reluctant to make the move, it is Erica who cannot seem to come to terms with her father's decision to relocate. It isn't until Erica captures the attention of Dave Porter—the captain of the Westwood Warriors hockey team—that life seems to come full circle. But when Dave dumps his current girlfriend to be with Erica, the horrors begin. Now, with Erica receiving terrible threats warning her to stay away from Dave, Matt finds a mysterious fountain pen under the rotted floorboards in his attic. Surprisingly, this pen has the power to bring to life any wish that he writes. But there is a catch. It will only fulfill evil wishes. What good is a pen that will only grant evil wishes? Matt finally comes up with an answer to this dilemma when Erica suddenly finds herself in the crosshairs of a murderous plot. Can Matt save his sister from an untimely death? Or will she become the first casualty of an unrequited love?