When Cinderella's glass slipper is stolen, Everafter's Queen Felicia sends her faithful steward, Terrance, to the "real" world to retrieve his love, and witch-in-training, Bianca Frost.

The power of the glass slipper, when paired with its mate, could ruin the peace of Everafter—especially in the wrong hands.

Together, Bianca, Ming, Prince Ferdinand, and Terrance venture deep into the heart of Everafter to seek clues as to who has stolen the slipper and why. Bianca must gather every bit of magic she has learned to find the coveted artifact and protect her new love.

Along the way, she will learn the risks of tampering with black magic and the high price that must be paid for any magic, even when used for good.

Bianca and Terrance's relationship will be put to the test. Bianca must decide if following her gallant boyfriend into his fantasy world is in fact her heart's desire.