Siobhan, alongside her brother-in-law Logan, begin tracking down their siblings. The most recent sibling they have found, Ben.

Ben's boyfriend Austin gets a surprise when his new stepsister Natalie is forced to move in with him. She just happens to be the girl he tormented in high school, and still can't keep his eyes off her.

Natalie finds herself in a relationship with not only Austin, but his friends Ben, River, and Gracie. Not only was Austin obsessed with Natalie, so was his father Colin, and Colin would do anything to get what he wants, and he wants Natalie.

Ben puts his faith in Siobhan and seeks her help when he needs help finding Natalie, just hoping they can get to her in time.