When Public Defender Emmy Mahoney runs into Rudy, one of her college crushes, he suggests they get together with the third member of their old group—Emmy's one-time flame Pete—to celebrate her upcoming birthday. When the flirting reaches scorching levels, one of the guys asks who she'd prefer to take home. Emmy, a little tipsy and brazen, declares she can't choose—she'll have to have them both.

Rudy and Pete, ever eager to please, offer themselves for Emmy's ménage à trois fantasy. The single evening turns into a full-fledged, sex-filled stay-cation. After a week of untold fantasies, Emmy wonders how they'll return to their former relationship...while the men have much more in mind.