Throughout American history, presidential legacies have been subjects of intense debate and analysis. In recent years, discussions have increasingly drawn parallels between two Democratic presidents: Jimmy Carter and Joe Biden. Both served single terms marked by significant challenges, leading some commentators to suggest that Biden's presidency mirrors Carter's in several respects. For instance, journalist Ronald Brownstein noted that both administrations faced economic difficulties and experienced declining public approval, culminating in electoral defeats for their party's subsequent candidates. ​

Public sentiment appears to reflect this assessment. A Gallup poll from December 2024 indicated that 54% of Americans anticipate that Biden will be remembered as a "below average" or "poor" president, with only 19% expecting a more favorable historical judgment. This perception aligns with Carter's post-presidential evaluations, suggesting a shared narrative between the two administrations.​

However, it's essential to approach such comparisons with nuance. While both presidents encountered economic hardships and foreign policy challenges, the contexts and specifics of their situations differed. For example, Carter's tenure was notably affected by the energy crisis and the Iran hostage situation, while Biden's presidency dealt with the COVID-19 pandemic and its economic aftermath. Additionally, Carter's post-presidential years were marked by significant humanitarian efforts, a legacy that continues to influence public perception.

The Worst American President delves into these complexities, examining the administrations of both Jimmy Carter and Joe Biden. By analyzing their policies, challenges, and enduring impacts, this book aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of their presidencies. It seeks to explore whether the parallels drawn between Carter and Biden are justified and what lessons can be learned from their experiences in the Oval Office.​