Jocelyn "Joss" Miller, a twenty-something barista, works at Sugar Creek Cafe, a hip coffeehouse with deep ties to the local arts and music community. Joss is finally feeling like she's found her purpose as her recently launched true crime podcast soars in popularity. With her family's blessings, Joss produces a special tribute to her grandfather.

What seems like a step towards healing instead sets off a firestorm of reactions in the community. There are a few who would rather not be reminded of how Joss's grandfather had been murdered years ago. When the staunchest protester is found dead, Joss becomes the number one suspect.