Kate is a professor with an abysmal dating track record and acute anxiety. Natalie is a carpenter whose only focus is making sure her little brother Kyle is safe and provided for after his parents abandoned him. Neither of them are looking for love, but sparks fly when they stumble into the same lesbian bar. But that night, Kate is drunk and spills an embarrassing amount about her desires. And when they find out that Kate is Kyle's professor, even more panic ensues. Armed with a motley crew of friends (who really need to admit their feelings for each other), a trans little brother, and a terrible ex who naturally turns up at precisely the wrong moment, the women will have to navigate finding their way back into love.