Almost a year after the murder that shook Lobell College to its core, the start of a new academic year brings familiar faces back to the scene of the crime. Daniel Rosenbaum starts his first year as dean of the English department and takes a hands-on role in advising students. Lily Peterson and Gianna d'Angelo return to continue their undergrad studies after the death of the professor they were both in love with.

Meanwhile, on the other side of the Hudson, Tony d'Angelo is working hard. With his sister back in college, it's all hands on deck to keep his dad's auto shop running and take care of his infant niece. He still finds time to spend most nights with his boyfriend, Daniel, although he can't seem to find the words to talk to his family about his relationship. Tony's life is exactly what he's always wanted it to be—so why does he feel like he's struggling to be himself?

When a Lobell professor is once again found murdered, the idyll of the last months is turned on its head. Can Tony and Daniel stay out of harm's way this time? Or will the fragile new peace they've found together be shattered?