Five years after their success in high school theater, Josh and Hannah are still together. However, life has made things complicated, and Josh and Hannah have made some decisions that don't sit too well with Hannah. During their final semester in college, Hannah begins questioning everything in her life. She decides that her relationship with Josh needs a break. Josh is heartbroken by this turn of events, but he remains steadfast in his love.

As their final semester in college progresses, Josh and Hannah find their way back to each other through school choices, family problems, and slightly meddling friends. Josh rediscovers his love of acting when he gets cast as the lead in Hannah's senior project. And Hannah discovers that the things she wants in life might not have changed all that much after all.