Melissa Carter returns to Cloverton for a quick visit to help her mother, but an eight-year-old matchmaker has other plans. Sophie Winters, determined to bring joy back into her dad Jake's life, enlists Melissa to join their family Christmas traditions.

Jake, a single dad and Christmas Tree Farm owner, isn't looking for change—until Melissa starts to warm his heart. As they revive the town's Christmas Angel Project, Melissa begins to wonder if Cloverton could be more than just a temporary stop.

Will the magic of the season convince her to stay, or will she leave behind the love waiting for her under the mistletoe?