When items go missing from the bakery where KatieAnn Mast whips up her special treats, evidence points to her as the thief. All will be forgiven if she confesses before her Persimmon Creek Amish community and promises to mend her ways. But KatieAnn is not guilty, and she refuses to kneel in confession to a crime she did not commit. Wouldn't lying be as bad as stealing?

To avoid shunning, KatieAnn travels to the Southern Maryland Amish community where her older sister, Rebecca, lives with her husband and six children. As the holidays approach, KatieAnn helps out at the community store and finds her relationship with Luke Troyer developing into more than friendship. Everything is turned upside down when items begin disappearing from the store.

How will KatieAnn clear her name before she is branded a thief by yet another community? Will she be shunned before she can convince everyone of the truth?