On the surface, Evan Dyer's life in Otter Lake seems picture perfect: he's a fairly successful entrepreneur and co-operator of a boarding house for young people with disabilities alongside his longtime girlfriend Rachel. The three young men currently living with them are a joy, despite their issues, and things couldn't be better. But Evan is a man with a past, and that past is quickly closing in on him. When Evan's secrets collide with those of one of his tenants, the end results threaten to destroy not only the idyllic life Evan's managed to build for himself, but the lives of those dearest to him. The only way out is to come clean and unravel a few long-buried mysteries before it's too late.