Penny & Tripp got their happily ever after, but the gypsy magic isn't quite finished with the women in Penny's family. Their daughter, Mabel, is unlucky in love—repeatedly—but best friend, Sam, is always there to pick up the pieces. Corralled in the friend zone, Sam waits for Mabel to return his feelings. It might take an unexpected visit to the Wild West and a little magic for Mabel to see what's been in front of her the whole time. Unless the town's sexy sheriff lassos her heart before Sam can make his bid.