As the daughter of a deacon, Amy Yoder knows all eyes are on her to set a good example by marrying an Amish man. But finding one has proven to be much easier said than done. When her mother secures a suitable match, Amy isn't expecting much, but Andrew turns out to be everything she hoped for in a husband.

The only trouble is, Andrew lives in Wisconsin, far from Amy's home. Determined to bridge the distance, Amy sets out to see if absence will make the heart grow fonder—or end their happily-ever-after before it begins.