Young Tituba is one of the youngest women in the Bliss family. As a descendant of one of the most famous witches in history, Great Ancestor Tituba, she and all of the women in her family guard a secret chocolate recipe that has brought them both fame and fortune. Though young Tituba is told to keep the chocolate recipe and the fact that she is a witch a secret, an unexpected outburst leads to big changes for her and her family as well.