When a set of remains are found at Willow Lake, Sheriff Wyatt Stone and his cousin, Deputy Derrick Stone learn the bones are that of a young girl, but not those of Willow Atwood who was abducted from the same spot five years ago. Searching the area reveals clues suggesting Willow may have returned, along with her abductor. However, Wyatt's focus becomes clouded when his estranged brother, Blake, returns to town...alone.

Life at the Redneck Ranch has found an easy rhythm for Harley Harper thanks to her blossoming romance with the handsome Sheriff. But an innocent encounter with Blake leaves her questioning hers and Wyatt's relationship after Wyatt assumes the worst.