Two college guys, Percy and Cas, meet at an American football game being held at their college campus when they realize they both hate the same guy, the star quarterback who stole their ex-girlfriends in the past and both are still not over. They get into a discussion about it while watching the game, as well as talk about other stuff, and eventually after the game decide to exchange numbers since they got along so well. But the more time they spend together both on campus and off campus the closer they grow to each other until feelings start developing and they have to choose between hiding their real identity as a gay man from everyone around them or revealing who they truly are for a chance at love.