When Martha discovers a story about lesbians in her niece's room, she's convinced she and Herbert made a grave mistake in sending Felicity to an all-girls high school. As Felicity's legal guardians, Martha and Herbert, battle it out about what should be done with the story–and with Felicity–Felicity has problems of her own: like what to do about the cool, confident girl she's been seeing all summer and what her feelings are for her.