Seth Harlow has always had a crush on his best friend from high school, Riley Palladino. When his best friend moves to his city they catch up and immediately the feelings are still there. But to his horror, one of Seth's friends, Emory Dallas, wants him to set her up with his best friend. Not wanting to come out and have anyone know about his feelings for Riley, he sets them up. At the same time, Riley and Seth start spending more time together and get closer to each other. But when Emory confesses her love for Riley and Seth realizes he's about to lose Riley, he has to choose between keeping his feelings a secret and seeing his best friend with someone else or revealing his true feelings for Seth. But Seth is straight and isn't Seth supposed to be too?